Tuesday, June 14, 2022

Actions and Attitudes, Motives and Methods

I just watched a video about antiheroes, and the video essayist looked for ways to categorize heroes, villains, and anti-heroes on a pair of graphs, with heroic and non-heroic Actions and Attitudes and Motives and Methods. As I watched this video, I couldn't help wondering where I would fall on these graphs.

My actions aren't exactly heroic, but they are generally good. I usually try to do the right thing, when I bother to do anything at all. Yet, I know my attitude could use some work. I usually do good, but I also usually do so reluctantly and/or resentfully.

My motives and methods are a little harder to pin down. My motives are a mix of good and bad ones. I generally like helping people, and I enjoy making people happy, but I also derive some motivation from just doing what I'm supposed to do. I'm motivated as much by an obligation to do good as by a genuine desire to. My methods are functionally irrelevant. A fictional character may have options in their choice of method. For example, when a fantasy character has to get into a city despite guards trying to keep them out, the fantasy character may try to trick the guards, sneak past them, bribe them, intimidate them, persuade them, kill them, or merely knock them out. There are plenty of ways to get into a guarded city, but there aren't that many different, meaningfully-significant ways to clean the house or church building or help my sister with food.

So, my methods are irrelevant, my motives are a mix, my actions are generally pretty good, but my attitudes are generally pretty bad. Of those four, I think it makes the most sense to work on my attitude, to stop complaining and grumbling so much, and to focus on the better motivations for doing good. If I'm doing good only because I "should" or because I "have to," it's easy to have a bad attitude about that. But if I focus on better motivations and do a better job of maintaining a good attitude, I can establish myself more firmly in a heroic quadrant than an anti-heroic quadrant.

I want to be a good person. I want to do good things in good ways for good reasons, and I want to maintain a good attitude while I do it. I know that's asking a lot, but I'm already about halfway there. Now I just need to work on my Motives and Attitude, and I should be almost entirely Good.

Paying for Prophecy

In 1 Samuel 9, a Benjamite named Saul, who would later become king of Israel, had a pressing issue to bring to the local seer, Samuel, but he had a problem. He had been traveling light, so when he considered the possibility of consulting the seer for guidance, he wondered what he could bring the seer as a gift. This struck me as odd, not because of the synonymity of the terms "prophet" and "seer," but because it's not a typical cultural practice for us to pay prophets for their guidance. We get our prophecies for free at least every six months. Then again, that may just be a difference in payment model. Saul, apparently, was using a pay-per-prophecy program, whereas we're on the subscription program. Rather than taking cash to the bishop, prophet, or temple whenever we have a burning question, we pay our tithing regularly and get inspired guidance frequently.

Granted, there's nothing wrong with this. It's not priestcraft; it's pragmatic. Those who have devoted their lives to the service of God, including the regularly-provided service of relaying prophecies from God, still need to eat. They are still mortal, and so long as they are mortal, they need to make a living somehow, and, by divine design, their vocation and calling are one and the same. Sure, I would love to be able to buy more specific guidance from time to time, but the system we have works well enough, especially when we account for the Holy Ghost helping to provide guidance as well.

At first, it seemed weird to read about Saul paying for a prophecy, but maybe it's not so weird after all. I mean, I'd do it if I could, and in a sense, we kind of already do.

Sunday, June 12, 2022

Don't Trust Others With Power

This evening, in our family scripture study, we read a reminder of why people shouldn't be trusted with too much power. In 1 Samuel 8, as elsewhere in scripture, the people want to have a king, but are warned against the harm a king can cause. Kings can tax and confiscate property, appoint taskmasters over the people, force people into difficult situations, and severely punish those who disobey. Kings are bad news.

But, naturally, it's not just kings. No one should be trusted with too much power over other people. Power corrupts, and those who have more power than accountability are prone to abuse that power. Thus, we shouldn't trust anyone with great power unless we also have a plan for how to hold them accountable if they abuse it.

As a general rule, I don't trust other people, especially not with power over other people. Instead, I believe strongly in individual moral agency and, when necessary, the power of persuasion. Instead of exercising power over other people, I would rather try to persuade them to do as I ask, and I would much rather be persuaded to cooperate than be forced to by those who want to exercise power over me. If you have a good reason to want me to do something, explain your reasoning to me. If you can't, then maybe your reasons aren't as good as you think.

Power in the wrong hands can be dangerous, and it can be hard to know whose hands are trustworthy, so, as a general rule, I don't trust anyone's. I don't trust other people to have or exercise power over me, and, as many scriptural examples illustrate, I don't think God would want me to.

Saturday, June 11, 2022

Should I Have Killed the Cockroaches?

So, remember when spent half the night wondering about the morality of squashing a bee that had become debilitated? Since then, I have had two experiences with killing insects that had the appearance of cockroaches. The first, I caught at home, and I immediately thought of flushing it down the toilet, but I was persuaded to keep the insect contained (in a foodless, waterless, nearly air-tight container) so its body and identity could be more thoroughly examined and identified later. The second insect, I spotted away from home while vacuuming, and, having no other way to quickly contain the creature, I vacuumed it up. In both cases, I caused the death of an insect that was mostly minding its own business, and I didn't feel even remotely bad about either of them, mostly because I believed their were cockroaches.

What bothers me about this isn't that I'm so callous about killing roach-like insects, but that I'm okay with killing roach-like insects more willingly than insects like flies or bees. There's no moral consistency there. Why would I give cockroaches (or insects with the appearance of cockroaches) less moral consideration than flies or bees? Why would I give flies and bees more moral consideration than cockroaches? It's inconsistent and illogical. Unless there's a moral difference between bees and cockroaches, I should treat them similarly.

Granted, there could be moral differences that make bees more worth sparing than cockroaches. Bees assist in the pollination of plants and the production of honey. Bees bring more joy into the world than cockroaches do. If human happiness is the main moral factor to consider, and bees bring more happiness than cockroaches do, then cockroaches deserve less moral consideration. Then again, I don't know enough about cockroaches to confidently identify them, let alone list their positive and negative qualities. I shouldn't be so quick to judge.

However, I'm not sure it matters much. Neither bees nor cockroaches are human, so neither of them deserve anywhere near as much moral consideration as a human. The deaths of these insects are probably entirely inconsequential in the grant scheme of things. It's probably just fine that I killed the bee the other day, and it's probably just as fine that I killed these probably-cockroaches more recently. I don't know if I "should have" killed the cockroaches, but I'm sure it's okay that I did.

Friday, June 10, 2022

Rough Start, Okay Finish

This morning was a little rough. Plans had to change, some tasks became harder than I expected, and I had a hard time finding the energy to keep going with my plans for the rest of the day. Thankfully, it ultimately went okay. I got the help I needed, took a breather when I had to, and I kept going forward with my chores and errands, ultimately succeeding in completing most of it. Today didn't go as well as I had hoped, but it went well enough, and I'm glad it went that well at least. Today could have been worse, especially given how roughly it started. I'm glad that, thanks to some help and diligence, the rest of the day was able to go okay.

Thursday, June 9, 2022

Nature is Beautiful

Nature is beautiful. That can sometimes be hard to remember, especially when the weather gets crumby, but there are places of great beauty in the world, and there are elements of beauty in nearly every environment.

Personally, I love mountains. Though I don't get to see them in person very often, I love to look at pictures of them, and I've joined a few groups on Facebook dedicated to sharing the kinds of landscape photographs I like to see. And in my own area of the world, we have trees, each of which has a unique beauty, in addition to their shadow-casting, temperature-regulating, and oxygen-producing benefits.

I love mountains, and I love trees. Granted, I'm not a huge fan of overly hot and sunny days, but I'll accept nature as it is an appreciate its beauty, despite its downsides. We're lucky to live in such a beautiful world. I hope that we all take the time to appreciate and preserve its natural beauty.

Should the Party Have Killed Arrigal?

Arrigal is an assassin and a theif. He attacked multiple party members, nearly killed them, and took a lot of their stuff, including much of the treasure they had earned over multiple quests and adventures. Granted, Arrigal had his reasons for doing so. He had stolen from the party in order to steal back stuff that he thought they had stolen, and he attacked them only to prevent them from preventing him from stealing back what had been stolen. And, yeah, he nearly killed them, and he could have killed them, but he deliberately didn't kill them, and he made sure to do no lasting damage. Frankly, the party got off easy. Had he wanted to TPK the party, he totally could have. Yet, he let them live long enough to learn he had stolen their stuff, and they tracked him down, cornered him, and had to figure out what to do with him.

It's worth noting that, by the time they grabbed him, he had already returned the stuff he had taken from them. As it turns out, his suspicions of them were only part correct. Yes, they had stolen from him and his group, but that was the only major act of stealing they had done. Once he learned this, he returned their treasure to them and attempted to slip away with his life. And when he failed and was captured, he cooperated with their interrogation to the best of his abilities. See, most of the party knew nothing about the theft that had caused Arrigal to attack the party; they only knew that he had attacked them, and they were understandably reluctant to let that slide. But after getting their stuff back and learning that he had only stolen from them because he thought they had stolen from him and others, they let him go.

Morally speaking, this was the right thing to do, but strategically speaking, I'm not sure this was a wise choice. Arrigal still has a bone to pick with the party, since the same theif who caused this whole problem in the first place also picked Arrigal's pockets while they had him captured. The party is too dangerous to risk crossing again, and it'd be wise for him to cut his losses and get out while he can, but he'd like his stuff back, and I would loathe to reward the immoral actions of a selfish theif. Perhaps Arrigal should steal his stuff back. And if anyone gets hurt trying to stop him, then that'll be a shame.

But I'm probably not going to do that. Arrigal is probably just going to leave the campaign setting and never interract with the story again, so he'll be safe from the party's misguided retribution. Or maybe I'll let him fully turn toward villainy, over-react, and commit overkill, the way only an assassin can. It's possible that I'll have Arrigal become a recurring, fatal threat to the party. Perhaps they should have killed him when they had the chance, before he kills them.

But he won't. As before, the knowledge of the potential to get petty revenge is probably enough for me. I don't actually need to kill player characters or actually, permanently steal (stolen goods) from them in order to enjoy this game. For me, it's good enough to know that Arrigal survived and can continue his story elsewhere, never intersecting with the party's story again.

So, no, the party should not have killed Arrigal, and I'm very glad they didn't.